| |
Poll No. 22
Withdrawal from Gaza, President’s Performance, Legislative Elections
[ Analysis of Results ][ Detailed Results ][ Sample Distribution ][
PDF Format ][
In Arabic ]
Main Results:
-
An increase in the President Performance Index (PPI) from 33% (during April
2005) to 40%.
-
There is a noticeable increase of support for President M. Abbas in Gaza
Strip, where the PPI jumped from 33% to 45% (12 points more)
-
Wide support of President Abbas' measures concerning the security situation in
Gaza, where more than 82% of the respondents supported his effort in putting
an end to the misuse of arms, chaos and public insecurity.
-
51% of the respondents believe that President Abbas is capable of implementing
his platform in regard to arms’ chaos and insecurity.
-
More than 74% of the respondents support a truce with Israel; in Gaza support
for a truce reaches 83%.
-
72% expressed their opposition to militant parades, carried out by some
factions; the percentage of opposition in Gaza Strip increases to 82%.
-
60% of the respondents still oppose the disarming of the various military
groups (brigades). The percentage of opposition to disarming in Gaza is 50%,
while the percentage of support is 45%.
-
Around 70% expect that there will be an improvement in the functioning of the
governmental institutions following the Israeli unilateral disengagement and
61% expect reinforcing the rule of law.
-
A Fateh bloc (headed by Marwan Barghouthi) would win 46% of the votes, while
Hamas bloc (if headed by Az- Zahhar) would win 23% of the votes. The National
Initiative (Al- Mubadara) would gain 7% of the vote (if headed by Mustafa
Barghouthi). On the other hand, a bloc comprised of both the Popular Front for
Liberation of Palestine (PFLP) and the Democratic Front for Liberation of
Palestine (DFLP) (headed by Ahmad Sa'adat) would gain 2.5%. The Peoples’ Party
- PPP (headed by Bassam Salhi) would gain about 1.4%. What is worth mentioning
here is that there will be a different voting pattern emerges with a change in
leadership of the blocs.
-
Marwan Barghouthi is the most popular candidate inside and outside Fateh,
where he gets 55% of the votes when compared with other Fateh candidates. Az-
Zahhar is the most popular candidate of Hamas' bloc (46%). Mustafa Barghouthi
is the most popular among the candidates of the (Third Way) at 53%.
Results Analysis:
Part I: The Israeli unilateral disengagement has a significant
impact on attitudes, especially in Gaza Strip.
1. Following the Israeli
unilateral disengagement substantial changes and major opinion shifts have been
noticed among Gazans. Among the most salient changes and shifts revealed by the
poll are as follows:
-
PPI in Gaza increased from 33% during April to be 45% at present (12 points
more).
-
47% of the respondents in Gaza Strip feel secure after the Israeli pull-out.
This is compared to 30% during December 2004. At the same time, 20% feel
secure (to some degree) and 34% do not feel secure (During 2004, 53% of Gaza
respondents felt insecure).
-
A majority of respondents (40%) in Gaza Strip considers ending the arms
anarchy, security chaos and the enforcement of the rule of law as its utmost
priority, only to be followed by improving the economic conditions (23%) and a
solution to the Palestinian prisoners and detainees’ problem (23%).
-
The support of truce among respondents in Gaza Strip is at 83%.
-
There is a noticeable, growing trend in Gaza Strip supporting the disarming
of the various military groups. Whereas 31% supported such move in 2004, this
poll shows that 46% of the respondents in Gaza Strip are in favor of it.
2. The Israeli disengagement deepens the perception gap between Gaza and the
West Bank:
-
69% of the respondents from the West Bank said that they do not feel secure,
while only 34% of the respondents from Gaza Strip share the same feeling (a
gap of 35 points).
-
39% of the respondents from the West Bank said that they are pessimistic,
whereas only 22% of the respondents from Gaza Strip expressed such an attitude
(17 points gap).
-
80% of the respondents in the West Bank considered President Abbas’
performance “good” or “fair”, whereas a positive evaluation of his performance
was 89 % in Gaza Strip (9 points gap).
-
The support of the truce among West Bank respondents reached 69% whereas 83%
of the respondents in Gaza expressed such an attitude (14 points gap).
-
The public support to disarm the various military groups reached 29% in the
West Bank, while 46% of the respondents in Gaza support this move (17 points
gap).
-
37% in the West Bank believe that the Israeli disengagement would improve the
performance of the Palestinian institutions, while 65% in Gaza Strip believe
in that (28 points gap).
-
Only 26% in the West Bank consider that the Israeli withdrawal would lead to
improvement in the economic conditions compared to 43% in Gaza Strip (17
points gap).
-
32% of the respondents in the West Bank think that the Israeli withdrawal
would lead to reinforcement of the rule of law compared to 54% in Gaza Strip
(22 points gap).
-
The majority, 61%, expects that the PNA will enforce order and the rule of
law. In the West Bank 55% of the respondents expressed this expectation
compared to 71%in Gaza Strip.
-
Among the respondents, 55% believe that the Israeli withdrawal will improve
the economic conditions (46% in the West Bank and 69% in Gaza).
-
Also, 56% of the respondents expect the strengthening and consolidation of the
relations between the West Bank and Gaza Strip as well as the interconnection
between the two areas in the wake of the Israeli disengagement (51% in the
West Bank and 64% in Gaza).
-
Among the West Bank respondents, 43% believe that the withdrawal will put an
end to the security disorder/anarchy and the arms’ chaos. In Gaza 58 % of the
respondents expressed such a belief.
Yet, the majority of the respondents (64%), in both the West Bank and
Gaza Strip, believe that the withdrawal from Gaza Strip would reinforce the
occupation in the West Bank and would fail to ease the closure.
3.
Ending Arms’ Chaos, the Enforcement of Order and the Rule
of Law is the Prime Priority
Concerning the most salient issues, which call for the attention of the
PNA in the wake of the Israeli withdrawal, the poll points to three major
issues: (a) ending the arms’ chaos, the enforcement of public order and the rule
of law; (b) the release of the Palestinian prisoners and detainees and; (c)
improving the economic conditions of the Palestinians.
-
38% of the respondents (simultaneously in the West Bank and Gaza Strip)
considered an end to the arms’ chaos and the enforcement of the rule of law as
their most significant priority.
-
Releasing Palestinian prisoners is the second priority (27%), while improving
the economic conditions is the third priority (23 %).
-
The rest of the issues linked to the Israeli unilateral disengagement did not
take the same urgency of the three mentioned above. For example, only 6.5% of
the respondents considered the easing of the siege on Palestinian cities as
their first priority. The issue of renewing the negotiation with Israel
considered a priority only by 3.4% of the respondents. Consolidating the
relations between Gaza and the West Bank won 2% of the respondents, while the
improvement of the performance of the Palestinian institutions gained 1.3
percent.
Part II: Rising Support for the President Mahmoud Abbas
1.
There is a growing trend of support for the President’s
election platform, that expresses a public longing for security in general,
personal security and order, especially in Gaza Strip.
-
Respondents, especially in Gaza Strip, expressed a wide support for President
Abbas' platform on the issues of bringing security, order and the control of
arms.
-
In general, 74% of Palestinians supported a truce agreement that prevents
attacks against Israel, while the percentage in Gaza Strip reached 83%.
-
82% supported what President Abbas suggested in his speech on 13/9/2005,
after the Israeli withdrawal, about fighting the arms’ chaos, public disorder
and the security anarchy. The support for the President's speech in Gaza Strip
reached 91%.
-
72% of the respondents opposed armed parades by the Palestinian groups within
Palestinian communities. In Gaza Strip the percentage of those who opposed the
conduct of such parades reached 82%.
-
93% of the surveyed considered storing ammunition, by some factions in
residential areas unacceptable.
-
The percentage of those who support the disarmament of militant groups of
various militant increased to reach 35% at present, while it was 28% during
December 2004. In Gaza the percentage increased from 31% to be 45% (14 points
more). Yet, the percentage of those who opposes this move i.e., to disarm the
military groups, remains high, especially in the West Bank where 66% adopts
such a stance compared to 50% in Gaza Strip. The total percentage (in the West
Bank and Gaza Strip) of those who oppose disarmament of military groups
remained 60%.
2.
Progress in the President’s Performance Index (PPI),
especially in Gaza
-
The PPI shows improvement, in both the West Bank and Gaza Strip, from 33% in
April 2004 to approximately 40% at present.
-
The major progress in the PPI was registered in Gaza Strip where it rose to
45% from 33% during April 2005 (12 points more). However, in the West Bank,
the PPI increased a little (three points) to reach 36% from 33% during April
2005.
-
President Abbas’ support varied depending on the issue at hand. The highest
grades of performance he received were from dealing with issues like:
improving the performance of the security apparatuses; support for Palestinian
women; democracy promotion; and achieving the Israeli withdrawal. On the other
hand, the low grades he received came from dealing with the following issues:
achieving public security; fighting corruption; working towards working
towards even development and equal distribution of resources between the
Palestinian areas.
The table below illustrates the
classification of the support for President Abbas, starting from the highest to
the lowest percentages of evaluation. Moreover, the table illuminates the
differences in the support he received from the West Bank and Gaza Strip. In
Gaza, President Abbas received high degrees of evaluation on his role in
achieving the Israeli withdrawal from Gaza Strip and for his role in promoting
democracy, support of women as well as for his role in upgrading the performance
of Palestinian security apparatuses. The evaluation of the President’s
performance in Gaza Strip is strikingly different from the West Bank.
|
Table 1: President’s Performance
According to the Quarterly index (from the highest to the lowest)
|
|
|
Total |
West Bank |
Gaza Strip |
|
1- Improving the performance of the security apparatuses |
48.3 |
48.0 |
48.9 |
|
2- Promoting the status of Women |
44.5 |
40.7 |
50.5 |
|
3- Promoting democracy and free speech |
43.7 |
39.1 |
51.1 |
|
4- Achieving the Israeli withdrawal |
43.1 |
36.6 |
53.5 |
|
5- Improve governmental institutions’ services for the general public
(ministries and official departments) |
40.1 |
37.8 |
43.7 |
|
6- Supporting Social Security Programs and Social Development |
39.3 |
36.0 |
44.4 |
|
7- Accomplishing justice in resource allocation between Palestinian
geographical areas |
32.8 |
30.1 |
37.2 |
|
8- Fighting corruption |
32.5 |
30.0 |
36.3 |
|
9- Achieving public and personal security |
31.9 |
26.3 |
40.9 |
|
President performance index (average) |
39.6 |
3.6 |
4.52 |
In another question that measures the present performance of the
President, 41% of the respondents consider his performance “good,” 42%
“moderate,” and 17% as “weak”.
Despite the improvement in the evaluation of President Abbas’
performance, the evaluation of the prime-minister, Ahmad Qurie’, remains the
same with no improvement, 25% of the respondents evaluate his performance as
“good,” 39% “moderate,” and 36% as “weak.”
Part III: The Upcoming Parliamentary Elections in January 2006
1.
The majority intends to participate:
-
67% of the respondents expressed their will to participate in the
parliamentary elections, while 28% indicated they will not.
-
About 20% of Palestinians state that they are a member of a political party
(17% in the West Bank and 24% in Gaza).
-
In view of the various scenarios for possible coalitions in the upcoming
legislative elections in January 2006, the following results surfaced.
2.
First Scenario: Open competition among all political
factions running separately
-
A significant percentage (24%) of possible voters are still undecided on how
they will vote.
-
Fateh bloc will win 46% of the votes in Gaza Strip and the West Bank, whereas
the geographic distribution in percentages will be 43% and 47%, respectively.
-
Hamas bloc would gain 23% of the votes. Hamas would win 21% of the West Bank
votes and 26% in Gaza Strip.
-
The percentage of voters for the bloc of the (PFLP) reached 2.3%, whereas its
support in the West Bank reached 2.9%, in Gaza Strip it is 1.5%.
-
The percentage of voting for the Peoples’ Party is 1.6%, Palestinian
Initiative 1.4%, and 1.1% for the (DFLP).
3.
Second Scenario: Blocs led by well-known leaders; a
coalition between PFLP and DFLP.
-
Compared with the first scenario, there is no change in the popularity of
Fateh if led by Marwan Bargouthi (at 46%).
-
Hamas gets the same vote if led by Az-Zahar (about 23%).
-
The dramatic change is in the vote for Al-Mubadara as led by Mustafa Bargouthi,
where its popularity goes from 1.4% to 7%.
-
A coalition between PFLP and DFLP does not lead to higher votes (they get
about 2.5%).
|
Table 2: Second scenario
|
|
|
Total |
West Bank |
Gaza Strip |
|
1- A bloc comprised of Fateh and other independents and headed by
Marwan Barghouthi |
46.3 |
49.9 |
41.5 |
|
2- A bloc comprised of Hamas and other independents and headed by
Mahmoud Az- Zahhar |
23.1 |
21.9 |
24.9 |
|
3- A bloc comprised of the National Initiative and other independents
and headed by Mustafa Barghouthi |
6.8 |
7.5 |
5.9 |
|
4- A bloc comprised of the Popular Front and the Democratic Front and
headed by Ahmad Sa'adat |
2.5 |
3.4 |
1.4 |
|
5- A bloc comprised of the Peoples’ Party and other workers
federations and headed by Bassam Salhi |
1.4 |
1.9 |
0.8 |
|
6- I will participate but I did not decide yet for which bloc I will
vote |
15.1 |
13.3 |
17.5 |
|
7- I will participate but I will not vote for any of the above blocs
and I am still waiting for the formation of new blocs |
4.6 |
2.1 |
8.0 |
4.4.Third scenario: changing Fateh leadership: Ahmad
Qurie’ instead of Marwan Barghouthi; Palestinian Initiative and independents: Hanan Ashrawi instead of Mustafa Barghouthi.
-
Fateh’s popularity goes down to 36% if led by Ahmad Qurie’.
-
Hamas’s popularity increases to 26%.
-
A coalition of Al-Mubadara and independents led by H. Ashrawi receives 5%.
|
Table 3: Third Scenario
|
|
|
Total |
West Bank |
Gaza Strip |
|
1- A bloc comprised of Fateh and other independents and headed by
Ahmad Qurie’ |
36.1 |
39.7 |
31.4 |
|
2- A bloc comprised of Hamas and other independents and headed by
Mahmoud Az- Zahhar |
26.4 |
25.9 |
27.1 |
|
3- A bloc comprised of the Palestinian Initiative and other
independents and headed by Hanan Ashrawi |
5.0 |
5.8 |
4.0 |
|
4- A bloc comprised of the Popular Front and the Democratic Front and
headed by Ahmad Sa'adat |
3.0 |
3.4 |
2.3 |
|
5- A bloc comprised of the Peoples’ Party and other workers
federations and headed by Bassam Salhi |
1.6 |
2.1 |
0.9 |
|
6- I will participate but I did not decide yet for which bloc I would
vote |
19.8 |
18.1 |
22.1 |
|
7- I will participate but I will not vote for any of the above blocs
and I am still waiting for the formation of new blocs |
8.1 |
5.0 |
12.2 |
5.
Fourth scenario: A bloc
comprised
of the PLFP and DFLP and the Peoples’ Party (PPP); Fateh led by Salam
Fayyad and Hamas led by Ismael Haneyya.
-
Fateh gets about 34% as led by S. Fayyad.
-
Hamas keeps the same support at 25%.
-
Al-Mubadara led by Mustafa Bargouthi gets 8.2%.
-
A bloc of (PFLP, DFLP and PPP) gets 4.1%.
-
Increase in the percentage of the undecided to 28%.
|
Table 4: Fourth Scenario
|
|
|
Total |
West Bank |
Gaza Strip |
|
1- A bloc comprised of Fateh and other independents and headed by
Salam Fayyad |
34.0 |
35.7 |
31.6 |
|
2- A bloc comprised of Hamas and other independents and headed by
Ismael Haneyya |
25.0 |
23.0 |
27.8 |
|
3- A bloc comprised of the Palestinian Initiative and other
independents and headed by Mustafa Barghouthi |
8.2 |
8.9 |
7.1 |
|
4- A bloc comprised of PFLP, DFLP and the Peoples’ Party, and other
independents and headed by Ahmad Sa'adat |
4.1 |
6.0 |
1.7 |
|
5- I will participate but I did not decide for which bloc I would vote |
20.6 |
20.9 |
20.1 |
|
6- I will participate but I will not vote for any of the above blocs
and I am still waiting for the formation of new blocs |
8.1 |
5.5 |
11.7 |
6. Fifth scenario:
Three coalitions only: Fateh, Hamas, and the “Third Way”; no leaders are
mentioned.
-
Fateh gets 47%.
-
Hamas keeps its 25%.
-
The “third way” gets less than 7%.
|
Table 5: Fifth Scenario |
|
|
Total |
West Bank |
Gaza Strip |
|
1- A bloc comprised of PFLP, DFLP, Peoples’ Party, Al-Mubadara,
Fida, Popular Struggle Front and Independents |
6.7 |
8.8 |
3.9 |
|
2- A bloc comprised of Hamas and its allies |
24.7 |
23.5 |
26.3 |
|
3- A bloc comprised of Fateh and its allies |
46.8 |
48.9 |
44.0 |
|
4- I will participate but I did not decide yet for which of those
blocs I will vote |
17.5 |
15.6 |
20.1 |
|
5- I will participate but I will not vote for any of the above blocs
and I am still waiting for the formation of new blocs |
4.2 |
3.1 |
5.7 |
7.
Sixth scenario: open competition between leaders
from various political groups
-
Marwan Barghouthi is the most popular candidate, Az- Zahhar comes second
and Mustafa Bargouthi third
Out of ten political figures, Marwan
Barghouthi gained 42.2% of the vote, Mahmoud Az- Zahhar 17.7%, and Mustafa
Barghouthi 10.7%. Concerning the voting for the remaining political figures, it
was as follows: Ismael Haneyya 9%, Ahmad Qurie' 8%, Hanan Ashrawi 5.1%, Salam
Fayyad 3.8%, Ahmad Sa'adat 2.1%, Bassam Salhi 0.9%, and Qais Abu Laila 0.6%.
8. Competition among Fateh leaders
Note: these results emerge in case of
competition within the same group. They do not necessarily represent the
popularity of the candidate in the general elections, but only the competition
inside the bloc itself.
-
Marwan Barghouthi gained 55% of the votes to lead Fateh block while Mohammed
Dahlan occupied the second position where he gained 14.7% (most of his votes
came from Gaza Strip where he got 29% compared to 3.5% in the West Bank). Saeb
Erikat came a close third where he gained 13.7%.
-
Among the remaining candidates of Fateh, Ahmad Qurie' won the fourth position
where he gained 6.4% of the votes then Salam Fayyad who gained 5.5%, while
Nabil Amr gained 3.2% and 1% for each of Dalal Salama and Jameela Saydam.
9.Competition among Hamas leaders.
-
The results show that Az- Zahhar is the most popular candidate among
Hamas candidates where he gained 40% of the votes. He gained more support, to
lead Hamas' bloc, in the West Bank (45%) than in Gaza Strip (34%).
-
In general, Ismaeil Haneyya occupied the second position among the candidates
of Hamas where he gained 32%, though he occupied the first position in Gaza
Strip where he gained 43%, compared to 34% for Az- Zahhar.
-
Hasan Yousef occupied the third position where he gained 10% where his support
was nearly the same in both the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
-
Hamed Bitawi came in fourth position and he gained a percentage of 7.2%, but
his support was limited to the West Bank, especially in the northern
governorates (12.9% in the West Bank compared to 0.3% in Gaza Strip).
-
Nizar Rayyan rated fifth (5.2%), then Mohammed Ghazal (2.8%), only to be
followed by Saeed Syam with (1.5%), while Jamal Tawil gained only (0.7%).
10.
Competition among (Third Way) leaders
-
Among eight candidates for the (third way), Mustafa Barghouthi was the most
popular candidate where he gained 53% of the vote. He gained 52% in the West
Bank and 54% in Gaza Strip.
-
Hanan Ashrawi came second at 16%.
-
Yaser Abed Rabo came third at 13%.
-
Ahmad Sa'adat came fourth at 11% of the votes.
-
Basam Salhi gained 3.6% and came in fifth place followed by Qais Abu Laila
1.3%, Sameer Gousha 1.2% and Zaheera Kamal 0.5%.
11.
For Fateh the best result is achieved when Fateh is mentioned
without any specific leader or if led by Marwan Bargouthi.
12.
The results for Hamas are very much the same under any
circumstances. Their support might change significantly depending on how the
(undecided) vote and on how other coalitions carry out their campaigns. Of
course, this is also true for other blocs.
13. The best results for the “Third Way” are
achieved through running as two different blocs: Al-Mubadara and Independents
led by Mustafa Bargouthi (8.2%), and all other groups combined together will
win(4.1%):
President Performance Index (PPI) is a quarterly evaluation index that
evaluates the implementation of the President’s electoral platform since he
was elected in January 2004 by applying a composite of nine different
indicators which we shall list later. The PPI does not necessarily represent
an evaluation of the President's current performance. The evaluation of the
President is illustrated later.
Top of this page |
DSP Home
|
|